Dear wondering Methods--
What is the big deal with letting children know how it feels to fail at some things sometimes? I dont get how we've become a society that is soooo sensitive to competition and failing that in doing so, we somehow crush a child's self esteem, having long-term psycological effects. We've created this fantasy world for kids that tells them they're AMAZINGLY GREAT at everything and that any type of effort is acceptable...but that's not REALITY, so I don't believe in that.
In the REAL WORLD everyone is not a winner.
In the REAL WORLD, people make mistakes and will fail at things.
In the REAL WORLD, some people will be better at some things than others.
That's just the way it is.
Why should we shelter children from learning the invaluable lesson of failue????
I don't get it.
So to answer the question, both methods SUCK!
If the child wins, she wins. If the child can't play worth a flip and loses, maybe it will motivate her to either become better at it or try something else that she's actually good at.
Because that's what people do in the REAL WORLD.